Squids favorite toy is a bendy straw. We have bought him numerous kitty toys and he just snubs them! He has a cat tunnel, a ton of colorful mice, feather toys, a tent, and cat nip balls. He plays with these things but not often. If we are drinking something with a straw he is all over it. He meows and purrs with his cute 'I love you' eyes and you can't help but give it to him. Here is a video of how he plays with the straw. He shoves it under a rug and then fights to get it out. When it's back out he shoves it under again. He can do this for over 30 minutes. He is a weird kitty man.
Enjoy the video!